eldertree
•
Manager of Imperial Park Realms
Posts: 847
Likes: 286
Ethnic Heritage: Chinese in a Chinese body
Gender Identity: Cis
|
Post by eldertree on Oct 6, 2016 15:09:30 GMT
Okay so I thought it was meant to be Japanese but apparently not because I see like peach mantou which is an element of Chineseness And like I wasn't aware Japanese have like a large pig sitting on lettuce or cabbage I thought that's more of a Chinese thing And while there is sushi I can also see dimsum baskets and pigeons and a roasted duck I thought those are more Chinese things? Like the dish aesthetic and portion size intended for a communal setting is conveying Chineseness and also I see like ceramic or clay jars for storing alcohol like rice wine aka mijiu or huangjiu or even baijiu or perhaps fermented sort of sauces?
|
|
eldertree
•
Manager of Imperial Park Realms
Posts: 847
Likes: 286
Ethnic Heritage: Chinese in a Chinese body
Gender Identity: Cis
|
Post by eldertree on Oct 6, 2016 15:22:11 GMT
The film may be hinting toward the immorality aka gluttony of Chinese people which is actually racist given that the director is Japanese. Like even though he included some Japanese items it was largely Chinese based and he assigned it a negative aspect because the parents greedily devoured Chinese looking foods and turned into pigs and the faceless ghoul (or whatever his name was) also stuffed large quantities of Chinese looking foods until he exploded or something like that Then to save herself she ate a Japanese rice ball thus conveying the idea that Japanese food is ~good~ and ~moral~ It's also very peculiar that the era is Heian themed which is a period of Japanese history marked by exuberant Chinese influences. It's interesting that a witch who has ~Western~ tastes saves her: So I think one way to look at this film is that it's a subtly anti-Chinese culture film about Japan abandoning the ~immoral~ and ~inferior~ Chineseness, whilst celebrating ~moral~ and ~superior~ Japaneseness, and embracing the ~Westerness~ that saved Japan. NB: The Witch represents the West for Japanese people because she has a twin sister, one was evil and one was good. But in the end the evil witch isn't so evil after all and has redeeming qualities or something like that. So I think the witch characterises the general sentiment of the West that the Japanese have: the West is both good and bad but ultimately good. Note the huge nose which is often used as a stereotype for Westerners:
|
|
eldertree
•
Manager of Imperial Park Realms
Posts: 847
Likes: 286
Ethnic Heritage: Chinese in a Chinese body
Gender Identity: Cis
|
Post by eldertree on Oct 6, 2016 15:51:33 GMT
And certainly to me the tunnel design is very Forbidden City-esque with the faded red paint Part of Yubaba's (the evil witch) room. Note the very "Chinese" themed aesthetic: Anti-Chinese culture messages?
|
|
defiancexyzz
•
Laureate of Rice Agricultures
Posts: 318
Likes: 495
|
Post by defiancexyzz on Oct 8, 2016 15:11:23 GMT
I've read some sources suggesting that the setting for Spirited Away was based on the Taiwanese town of Jiufen (https://munchies.vice.com/en/articles/in-jiufen-you-can-eat-your-way-through-a-miyazaki-film).
Miyazaki himself is a genius who always created movies from the heart. He is a staunch pacifist holding the opinion that Japan should come to terms with its inner demons and apologize explicitly for its role across Asia during WWII.
His final film was poignant critique of the Japanese war machine (http://www.wnyc.org/story/hayao-miyazakis-final-film-is-an-uneasy-love-letter-to-a-war-machine/). As a result, he's been viciously and unfairly attacked by Japanese ultranationalists.
This speaks highly of Miyazaki. His enlightened views are a stark contrast to blathering idiots like EB88's 'Japanese' mod, MrC-rap.
|
|
foheadDynasty
•
Royal patron of the Palace Arts
Posts: 620
Likes: 196
Ethnic Heritage: Celestial manifestation
Gender Identity: Dominatrix
|
Post by foheadDynasty on Oct 8, 2016 17:17:57 GMT
That is the hidden psychology of Miyazaki. To unravel it would be to peer into the consciousness of the Japanese. Japanese people have taken Chinese influences but they think they are superior to it which needless to say is completely insulting to Chinese people. You hit the nail on the head when you discovered that the medicine was a Japanese rice ball but all the other stuff that was eaten looked Chinese.
If the film was severely racist then it might also have been the deviously concocted scene of the trip on the phantom train, if I remember correctly. It appeared to transport people having black skin and whose physical features appeared to have been inspired by African American folk art. The only redeeming thing I can think about that is if it was a symbolic gesture to suggest that black people became liberated from slavery but it seemed far more likely that it was touching on the note of how black people are segregated in Japanese society.
|
|